The unfold of the coronavirus has created unprecedented issues for Congress because it confronts tips on how to conduct legislative enterprise after the an infection of a number of members.

Sen. Josh Hawley, R-Mo., advised Politico, “We most likely can’t preserve working multi functional location.”

For all of U.S. historical past to this point, the Home and Senate have needed to take votes in particular person, of their respective chambers. Now, public well being measures might forestall that.

As a former counsel for the Home of Representatives from 1976 to 1983, I consider the Structure permits Congress to make use of a technique of voting aside from gathering on the ground of their legislative chambers.

Framers’ language

The Framers who designed the constitutional construction for the way issues would work in Congress based mostly it on parliamentary and colonial practices.

Members of Congress had and nonetheless must vote in particular person on the ground of the Home or Senate. However when the primary Congress formally convened on March 4, 1789, because of dangerous climate and troublesome journey, a quorum was not current. With no quorum – a easy majority – there weren’t sufficient members there to truly conduct enterprise. The ballots for president and vp couldn’t be counted and no laws might be handed or income raised. A quorum lastly assembled on April 1 within the Home and April 5 within the Senate.

The Framers won’t have anticipated the extraordinary steps that Congress must soak up a disaster equivalent to at present, when public well being measures may dictate that lots of of members be prevented from assembly on the ground of the Home or Senate.

But the language the Founders used 233 years in the past might however allow technological improvements now to facilitate voting from locations aside from the precise bodily Home and Senate chambers.

One of many first digital voting machines utilized by the Home, after digital voting was launched in 1973.
Home of Representatives

Leeway within the guidelines

The U.S. Structure directs that Congress “shall assemble” not less than yearly.

Whereas the dictionary definition of “assemble” consists of “to satisfy” or “to collect,” there is no such thing as a indication that digital meeting can be prohibited beneath the Structure.

What steerage the Structure gives suggests vast leeway in deciding tips on how to fulfill its necessities.

For instance, the Structure says {that a} “majority of every [house] shall represent a quorum to do enterprise” however doesn’t specify how every home ought to decide what constitutes a quorum.

For years, till 1890, the view within the Home was that satisfying the requirement for a quorum meant an absolute majority of members dwelling and seated needed to vote on any proposition. This resulted in members refusing to forged votes and thereby stopping a quorum and obstructing the Home’s enterprise.

In 1890, Speaker Thomas Reed dominated that members current within the chamber however not voting can be counted in figuring out a quorum.

Speaker Thomas Brackett Reed in 1890 made an vital change in Home voting guidelines.
Library of Congress Prints and Pictures Division, Brady-Helpful {Photograph} Assortment

The Supreme Courtroom upheld Reed’s rule, saying that the Home’s skill to transact enterprise is “created by a mere presence of a majority.” Since there was no technique specified within the Structure for figuring out the presence of a majority, it thus lay within the Home’s palms “to prescribe any technique which shall be fairly sure to determine the very fact.”

The Senate has a barely totally different rule however has the identical discretion to make an identical willpower.

Congress could make its personal guidelines

How Congress works will not be dictated solely by what’s constitutional. There are guidelines throughout the Home and Senate that additionally govern what every physique can do.

At present, Home guidelines say that “[e]very Member shall be current throughout the Corridor throughout its sittings … and shall vote on every query put.”

The Structure permits every home of Congress “to find out the Guidelines of its Proceedings.” The constitutionality of these guidelines has been challenged through the years, however the Supreme Courtroom has stated that Congress’ energy to formulate and impose such guidelines is “absolute and past the problem of some other physique or tribunal.”

Which means each the Home and Senate have the ability to amend their guidelines to permit a technique of voting that doesn’t require them to assemble on the ground of their chambers.

Securing the vote

This transformation might be constitutionally allowed and technically possible. However it raises many different questions, from individuals’s religion in Congress’ trustworthiness to the vulnerability of such a system to outdoors assaults.

If Congress adopts distant voting, its main problem is to create a system that may be protected in opposition to fraud, hacking or proxy voting.

Whereas the Senate nonetheless requires voice or hand votes, the Home applied digital voting methods within the early 1970s. By the 1980s, suspicions had arisen that Home members, both for his or her comfort or to keep away from an absence, lent their digital voting playing cards to at least one one other to enter their votes. Since no Home rule particularly allowed such proxy voting on the ground, there was a query of whether or not such a observe was permissible beneath Home Ethics guidelines.

Following a Home Ethics Committee investigation into these anomalies, they adopted a rule stopping proxy voting on the Home ground. Clearly the Home must give you a system for stopping such abuses from recurring.

After all, such a system might be devised for restricted use throughout emergencies, with a return to conventional voting within the chamber as soon as the emergency has handed.

[You’re sensible and curious in regards to the world. So are The Dialog’s authors and editors. You may get our highlights every weekend.]


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here